Introduction: The Critical Importance of Choosing the Right Scale
At the core of methods and time engineering lies a subjective but crucial judgment: activity rating or performance rating. This assessment of working speed relative to normal pace determines the accuracy of your standard times, the fairness of incentive systems and, ultimately, the competitiveness of your plant. For decades, two systems have dominated: the historic Bedaux System (60-point scale) and the Centesimal Scale (100-point or percentage scale). This comprehensive guide examines their technical foundations, applicability in modern industry and alignment with current regulations to help you make an informed, strategic decision.
1. Technical Foundations: What Defines Each Scale?
1.1. The Bedaux System: Industrial Heritage and Its 60-Point Philosophy
- Historical Origin and Key Concept: Developed by Charles Bedaux in the 1910s, it introduces the concept of the "B-point". Normal pace (100% activity) equals 60 B per hour, designed to be sustainable throughout the working day.
- Structure and Calculation:
- 0 B: Absolute rest.
- 60 B: Reference normal pace.
- >60 B: Accelerated pace (e.g. 72B = 120% activity).
- Typical Formula:
TE = (TO * (60 / Valoración en B)) + (MA * TO)
- Analysis of Advantages and Critical Limitations:
- Historical Advantage: Arithmetic simplicity in the pre-digital era.
- Main Limitation: Low granularity. The scale offers few intermediate points, hampering precision in detailed studies. A 50B vs. 55B represents a 10% difference in performance, but the scale allows no nuance.
1.2. The Centesimal Scale (100 Points): The OIT Standard
- Origin and Philosophy: Standardized by the International Labour Organization (OIT). It defines normal pace as 100% activity.
- Structure and Calculation:
- 0%: Total rest.
- 100%: Sustainable normal pace.
- >100%: Accelerated pace (e.g. 125%).
- Formula:
TE = (TO * (100 / % Valoración)) + (MA * TO)
- Fundamental Technical Advantages:
- High Granularity: Enables precise ratings (105%, 112%), essential for predetermined systems such as MTM or MOST.
- Intuitive and Universal: The percentage concept is immediately understandable across the whole organization.
- Regulatory Alignment: It is the system recommended by the OIT and the basis of modern certifications.
1.3. The BSI Scale (75/100): the classic British scale
- Origin and Philosophy: Scale of the British Standards Institution (BSI), historically widespread in British practice. It defines normal pace as 75 and fast pace as 100.
- Relationship with the centesimal scale: it is proportional to it (centesimal = BSI × 4/3), so that 75 BSI = 100 centesimal and 100 BSI = 133 centesimal. It measures exactly the same thing with a different numerical anchor: anyone at 75 BSI is at their normal pace.
2. Comparative Analysis in Industry 4.0
The choice is not only technical, but strategic. Integration with digital tools is a decisive factor.
| Criterion | Bedaux System (60B) | Centesimal Scale (100%) | 2025 Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | Low (few intermediate points) | High (1% granularity) | Centesimal |
| Software Integration | Requires constant conversion | Native in MES, BI, Induly | Centesimal |
| Analyst Training | Simpler initially | Requires rigorous calibration | Tie |
| Workforce Acceptance | May be perceived as archaic | Transparent and modern | Centesimal |
| Alignment with OIT/ISO | Not aligned | Fully aligned | Centesimal |
| Compatibility with MTM/MOST | Low (requires adaptations) | High (designed for it) | Centesimal |
Practical Calculation Example: Imagine an operator whose observed time (TO) on an operation is 0.120 min. The analyst assigns a rating of 115% on the centesimal scale or 69B on Bedaux. Let us assume an attention allowance (MA) of 12%.
With the Centesimal Scale:
TE = (0.120 * (100 / 115)) + (0.12 * 0.120)TE = (0.120 * 0.8696) + 0.0144TE = 0.1044 + 0.0144 = **0.1188 min**With the Bedaux System:
TE = (0.120 * (60 / 69)) + (0.12 * 0.120)TE = (0.120 * 0.8696) + 0.0144TE = 0.1044 + 0.0144 = **0.1188 min**
Result: The final standard time is identical. The difference lies in the perception and ease of judgment: for the analyst, it is more intuitive to judge "15% faster than normal" than "an activity of 69B". This intuitiveness translates into greater consistency among analysts, a critical factor for the credibility of the system.
3. Legal Context and Best Practices in 2025
3.1. The Regulatory Framework
There is no law prohibiting the Bedaux system, but the reference framework puts it at a disadvantage:
- Collective Agreements: The trend in negotiations is to specify "in accordance with OIT standards", which implicitly embraces the centesimal scale.
- Case Law: In disputes over incentives, courts give greater credibility to methods aligned with international standards (OIT), which are those based on the percentage scale.
- Certifications: Methods engineering training programs (including predetermined systems) are based on the 100-point scale.
3.2. Industrial Trend and Digitalization
The measurement of OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) and real-time production analytics require granular, comparable data. Tools such as WorkSamp for work sampling studies (Work Sampling) or production control systems such as Induly are designed to process and visualize data based on efficiency percentages. The centesimal scale integrates seamlessly into this digital ecosystem, whereas Bedaux introduces an unnecessary conversion layer that can generate errors and mistrust in the data.
4. Strategic Recommendation for 2025
For a plant seeking competitiveness, accuracy and alignment with the future, the choice is clear:
Implement and standardize the Centesimal Scale (100 points) if:
- You are starting a new work measurement system.
- You use or plan to use predetermined systems (MTM, MOST).
- Your Industry 4.0 strategy involves integrating real-time productivity data.
- You seek maximum acceptance and transparency in your incentive systems.
Consider keeping (with a transition plan) the Bedaux System only if:
- You have a historic incentive system based on it, with a workforce that understands and accepts it, and the cost of change is prohibitive in the short term. Even so, a medium-term migration plan is highly recommended.
Conclusion
The evolution of methods engineering toward precision and digital integration has left the Bedaux System as a historical relic of pedagogical value, but with very limited practical applicability in modern industry. The Centesimal Scale, with its granularity, intuitiveness and alignment with the global OIT standards, has established itself as the technical and strategic tool for work analysis in 2025. Choosing it is not only a matter of technical accuracy, but a decision aligned with transparency, fairness and the digital future of manufacturing.
Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800
If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.