How is productivity measured when the manufacturing cycle takes 4 hours and the operator appears to be "idle" in front of a control panel?
This is the most frequent —and costly— technical dilemma in modern methods engineering. A systemic error in the process industries (pharmaceutical, petrochemical, cosmetics and food) is attempting to apply time study methodologies designed for discrete manufacturing (parts assembly) in continuous reaction or batch (batch) environments.
In this technical guide, we break down Specialized Technique #14 from Cronometras. We analyze the definitive methodology for calculating standard times, saturation and real OEE in process industries, strictly aligned with the prevention and projected ergonomics regulations for the 2025 horizon.
The Inactivity Paradox: Manual Work vs. Dominant Technological Time
The first obstacle for a time study analyst in a chemical plant is the visual discontinuity of the cycle. Unlike an automotive assembly line, here the operator does not set the pace; the reactor does. This gives rise to what we call in methods engineering the "Inactivity Paradox".
1. Definition of Active Monitoring (ILO Standards)
Watching an operator observing a pressure gauge or monitoring a temperature curve on a SCADA system is not "idleness". According to the standards of the ILO (International Labour Organization), this is classified as Active Monitoring Time or Attention Time. There is a significant mental workload: the operator is managing the uncertainty of an exothermic reaction or a critical pressure.
Ignoring this time or classifying it as "avoidable inactivity" distorts the saturation calculation and puts process safety at risk.
2. Phase Classification for Time Study
To model these processes correctly, Technique #14 requires breaking down the "cycle time" into three airtight categories:
- External Manual Phase: Physical tasks such as loading raw materials (sacks, drums), connecting hoses or final packaging. These can be measured using Decimal-Hour Time Study or MTM systems.
- Technological Phase (Black Box): Reaction, mixing, fermentation or centrifuging. This is a Dominant Machine Time (DMT). Here the stopwatch is useless; the data must be extracted through integration with PLCs.
- Frequent Manual Phase (The Chaos Variable): Quality (QC) sampling, valve adjustments or in-process pH corrections.
Hybrid Methodology: Why Decimal-Hour Time Study Fails in the Chemical Sector
Attempting to time-study an 8-hour batch cycle with an analyst present 100% of the time (continuous time study) is financially unviable and statistically inefficient. Observer fatigue and the intrinsic variability of the chemical process invalidate the results.
At Cronometras, we implement a Hybrid Methodology for these scenarios:
1. Work Sampling (Work Sampling / Tippett Technique)
For long process phases, we replace the stopwatch with statistics.
- Application: Performing instantaneous random observations to determine the percentage of time devoted to Operation, Monitoring, Movement and Inactivity.
- Mathematical Rigor: We work with a Confidence Level of 95% and a maximum margin of error of ±5%. This makes it possible to audit entire shifts without the constant presence of an engineer.
2. Standardization with MTM-2 and MOST
Loading raw materials into reactors is a high-wear task. A fatigued operator alters their pace (Activity < 100). Assessing this pace "by eye" (Activity Rating) is subjective and a source of union disputes.
- Solution: We use predetermined times (MTM-2 or MOST). By assigning standard times to basic movements, we eliminate subjectivity and obtain a fair baseline time, independent of the operator's momentary fatigue.
2025 Regulatory Framework: Impact of ISO 11228 and Rest Allowances (K)
The legal landscape in Spain and the EU is changing drastically. The updates to the Prevention Act and the UNE-EN ISO 11228 ergonomics standard require fatigue allowances to be reassessed.
The Risk of Obsolete Allowances
Historically, rest allowances (K Allowances) of 11-12% have been applied. However, the chemical environment presents aggressive conditions that the new ILO tables penalize severely:
- Use of complex PPE (chemical suits, self-contained respirators).
- Work in ATEX zones.
- Thermal stress (heat/humidity in reactor areas).
Technical Projection: To comply with the 2025 regulations, allowances in process plants will have to be adjusted to the 18% to 25% range.
Warning: Maintaining standard times calculated with old coefficients is not only unrealistic, but will be legally indefensible before a labor inspection or an ergonomics audit.
Benchmarking: OEE and Saturation Indicators in Process Plants
Based on our Technical Market Research Report (2023-2024), we have identified critical gaps in sector efficiency:
| Indicator | Current Average (Chemical Sector) | Best-in-Class Target |
|---|---|---|
| Overall OEE | 60% - 65% | > 85% |
| Operator Saturation | 45% - 55% | 75% - 80% |
| Cycle Variability | ± 15% | ± 2% |
The Hidden Enemy: CIP and SIP
70% of OEE inefficiencies do not come from reaction speed, but from Cleaning (CIP) and Sterilization (SIP) times. Often, these times are "hidden" in maintenance codes or unplanned stoppages, accounting for up to 20% of total available time without being standardized.
Cronometras Solutions: Technical Optimization and Man-Machine Charts
To move from an OEE of 60% to 85%, measurement is only the first step. Optimization requires advanced methods engineering:
1. SMED Applied to Cleaning Processes
We treat reactor cleaning like a Formula 1 changeover.
- Conversion: We transform internal times (preparing detergents, purges, connecting hoses with the reactor stopped) into external times (off-line preparation).
- Result: A drastic reduction in Changeover, freeing up hours of productive capacity.
2. Man-Machine (M-M) Charts and Saturation from Interferences
How many reactors can one operator attend to safely? We use M-M Charts to visualize and calculate interferences: moments when two or more pieces of equipment require simultaneous attention (alarms, loadings). This allows us to define the Optimal Staffing of personnel, balancing physical saturation with the mental workload required to monitor critical processes.
3. Data Digitalization (Real-Time OEE)
Paper time study is dead. We integrate the calculated standard times (via MTM/Sampling) with the logs of your MES/SCADA systems. This provides a dynamic OEE that distinguishes between a performance drop caused by a machine failure and one caused by operational inefficiency.
Would your standard times withstand an audit under the 2025 regulations?
Measurement in continuous processes requires precision engineering, not just a stopwatch. If your plant operates with generic fatigue allowances or does not know the real impact of your cleaning times on OEE, your cost structure is compromised.
At Cronometras, we diagnose your real OEE, apply Technique #14 and adjust your fatigue coefficients to safeguard your productivity and compliance before the new European standards.
[> Request a Technical Time Study Audit (Confidential Report)]
Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800
If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.