Executive summary
Beer and soft drink bottling lines are probably the most complex industrial asset to measure within high-speed discrete manufacturing: a single line can fill between 30.000 and 80.000 bottles per hour (BPH) according to the technical data published by manufacturers such as Krones, Sidel, Co.Mac. and SÜKAT/Sunswell, with architectures of 4 to 7 synchronized stations (depalletizer, bottle washer, isobaric or volumetric filler, crowner or capper, labeler, shrink wrapper, palletizer). Any stopwatch applied "by eye" in this environment measures noise, not processes. This article presents the time-study methodology adapted to BPH lines: how to break a line down into measurable macro-elements with MTM, how to calculate the standard time per bottle using the nominal rate and the OEE efficiency of the sector (55-65 % according to the benchmarks published by Vorne Industries and SYMESTIC for FMCG/beverages, indicative values), how to apply SMED to format changeovers between a 33 cL glass bottle and a 33 cL or 50 cL can, and a simulated practical audit case in a Spanish plant producing 41 million hectoliters/year (data from the Socioeconomic Report on the Beer Sector in Spain 2024, produced by Cerveceros de España).
Key fact: Spain produced 41,29 million hectoliters of beer in 2024, being the second largest European producer, behind only Germany. The sector is concentrated in four groups (Mahou San Miguel, Damm, Heineken España and Hijos de Rivera/Estrella Galicia), which account for 9 out of every 10 beers consumed in the country. Source: Cerveceros de España — Socioeconomic Report 2024 and AETCM.
1. Why time-studying a bottling line is different from time-studying a lathe
1.1. The trap of the "time per bottle" calculated from capacity
The most common mistake when asking a plant manager for the standard time per bottle is that they answer with the inverse of the nominal capacity:
t_botella (s) = 3600 / BPH_nominales
For a 36.000 BPH line this gives 0,1 seconds per bottle. The figure is misleading for two reasons: (a) it is not a measurable time but a theoretical machine rate, and (b) a line never operates at 100 % of nominal capacity — the real OEE of the beverage sector moves around 55-65 % (Vorne/SYMESTIC, indicative values). Therefore, the inverse of real BPH is:
t_botella_real (s) = 3600 / (BPH_nominales × OEE/100)
For 36.000 BPH with OEE = 70 %, the real time per bottle is 0,143 s — 43 % higher than the nominal one. That difference is exactly what justifies a formal time study.
1.2. The heterogeneity of the cycle
Unlike a machining process (CNC lathe, press) where every part goes through the same closed cycle, a bottling line has asynchronous stations with different rates:
| Station | Operation | Typical rate |
|---|---|---|
| Depalletizer | Feeds empty bottles from pallet | 30.000-80.000 BPH (in line with the line) |
| Bottle washer (returnable glass) | CIP washing with water + caustic soda + rinsing | 8.000-30.000 BPH (bottleneck) |
| Isobaric filler | Counter-pressure filling (beer) or volumetric (soft drink) | 30.000-80.000 BPH |
| Crowner / capper | Metal closure (crown cap) or screw cap (PET) | Synchronized with filler |
| Labeler | Neck + body + back label | Synchronized |
| Shrink wrapper / packer | 6, 12, 24-unit pack | Synchronized or slightly lower |
| Palletizer | Robotic palletizing | Synchronized |
The bottleneck is usually the bottle washer (in plants with returnable glass, where bottles must be cleaned) or the pasteurization tunnel (in unfiltered beer). The time study must identify which is the real constraint, since the other stations operate with slack.
1.3. The environment problem: humidity, cold, noise
Bottling plants operate under conditions far removed from a laboratory. The allowances for environmental conditions handled in the ILO tables (indicative values) break down as follows:
- Damp environment (clean): +3 % over normal time
- Wet environment (water on the operator): +5 %
- Hot environment (30-35 °C): +5 % to +10 %
- Continuous noise > 90 dB(A): +2 % to +5 %
An operator in a pasteurization tunnel at 32 °C with 90 % relative humidity works with a combined allowance of 15-18 % over normal time (indicative example). Ignoring this factor leads to undersized time studies and to shifts that cannot be covered.
2. The MTM breakdown of a BPH line
2.1. Why MTM and not continuous stopwatch timing
At rates of 36.000 BPH, the time per station is around 0,1-0,3 seconds. A conventional digital stopwatch has a resolution of 0,01-0,1 s and an operator triggering error between 0,05 and 0,15 s. In other words, the measurement error is comparable to the time being measured. That is why the correct technique is MTM (Methods-Time Measurement) or MOST (Maynard Operation Sequence Technique), which assign predetermined times to micro-movements based on standardized databases:
- MTM-1: 1 TMU = 0,036 s (1/100.000 h); full database of predetermined micro-motion times.
- MTM-2: simplified version, accurate enough for BPH lines.
- MOST: 3 sequences (general move, controlled move and tool use), even faster to apply.
For a 60.000 BPH line with 7 stations, the estimated MTM time per bottle is on the order of 10-20 TMU (indicative figure), which gives a normal time per bottle of 0,4-0,7 seconds before allowances. This is the figure that is compared against the inverse of BPH to detect slack.
2.2. Example: MTM breakdown of the filling station
The isobaric filler (typical of beer) performs six main movements per bottle (indicative example with illustrative MTM codes and cumulative times referred to every 100 bottles):
| MTM movement | Code | TMU | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottle enters the wheel (transfer from washer) | AA4 | 35 | Move in space, short reach |
| Positioning under the filling valve | AB5 | 30 | Reach to fixed position |
| Raise bottle against valve (counter-pressure) | B30 | 30 | Basic move to the working plane |
| Hold during filling (counter-pressure + filling) | G4B | 25 | Light load control |
| Lower filled bottle | A10 | 10 | Simple basic move |
| Transfer to crowner | AA2 | 20 | Move in space, minimum reach |
| Total MTM-1 (per 100 bottles) | 150 TMU | = 5,4 seconds / 100 bottles |
Compared with the nominal rate of the filler (on a 36.000 BPH line = 100 ms/bottle), MTM predicts 150 TMU per 100 bottles = 5,4 s = 54 ms/bottle, leaving 46 % slack over the nominal. That slack is what is lost through breakdowns, micro-stops and start-ups; it is exactly what OEE captures.
2.3. How the standard time per stage is calculated
The general formula is:
Standard time = Normal time × (1 + Allowances)
For a stage with TMU = 150, performance rating = 100 (ILO standard pace) and allowances of 18 % (wet + hot + noise):
Standard time = 150 × (100/100) × (1 + 0,18) = 177 TMU = 6,37 seconds / 100 bottles
The allowance recommended for the beverage sector, based on the ILO allowance tables, breaks down as follows (indicative values):
| Item | % on NT |
|---|---|
| Allowance for personal needs | 5 % |
| Basic fatigue allowance | 4 % |
| Wet/hot work | +5-10 % |
| Noise > 90 dB(A) | +2-3 % |
| Slightly uncomfortable posture (standing with short movements) | +2 % |
| Typical total in beer filling | 18-24 % |
3. Capacity, OEE and industry benchmarks
3.1. The hierarchy of capacities
In a bottling plant, three capacities must be distinguished:
- Installed capacity: the manufacturer's figure (nameplate data). In fillers of the Krones Modulfill family, on the order of 78.000 BPH in non-returnable glass and 36.000 BPH in returnable glass (indicative figures; check the technical datasheet of the installed model).
- Nominal design capacity: the one defined by the designer considering the real bottleneck. Around 70-80 % of installed capacity (indicative figure).
- Effective capacity: what the plant produces after deducting planned stoppages, breakdowns and micro-stops. Approximated by:
Capacidad_efectiva (BPH) = BPH_nominales × OEE/100
3.2. Published OEE benchmarks for FMCG and beverages
According to data published by SYMESTIC and Vorne Industries for the beverage sector in European plants (indicative values), typical values are:
| Level | OEE | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Industry average | 55-65 % | Frequent unplanned stoppages, long format changeovers, untracked micro-stops |
| Good operational level | 70-80 % | Robust preventive maintenance, SMED implemented, micro-stop analysis |
| World-class | 85 %+ | Mature TPM, MES/ERP integration, zero changeover losses |
Key fact: the typical OEE of the FMCG/beverage industry moves around 55-65 %, while world-class plants exceed 85 % (indicative values according to the benchmarks published by SYMESTIC and iFactory).
3.3. Availability × Performance × Quality
OEE breaks down into three factors:
OEE = Availability × Performance × Quality
- Availability = (Actual running time) / (Planned time). Typical in brewing: 85-92 %.
- Performance = (Actual speed) / (Nominal speed). Typical: 80-95 %.
- Quality = (Conforming bottles) / (Total bottles). Typical in beer: 98-99,5 % (glass breakage, incorrect fill level, misaligned labeling).
For a plant with OEE 68 %, one could have, for example, A = 0,90, P = 0,80, Q = 0,94. The performance factor is usually the weakest and the one that benefits most from a well-done MTM time study, because it identifies underused operational slack.
4. SMED applied to format changeovers in beer
4.1. The economics of changeovers
A multi-product plant producing 8-12 different references (lager, amber, IPA, alcohol-free, private labels) may end up making 2-4 format changeovers per 8-hour shift. If each changeover lasts 90 minutes and is done 3 times a day, that is 4,5 h/shift (56 % of the working day) without producing. Reducing the changeover to 25 minutes (SMED target) frees up 3,3 additional hours of production per shift.
4.2. Phases of SMED on a BPH line
Applying the SMED method by Shigeo Shingo (phase results taken as an indicative example):
| Phase | Activity | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Phase 0 — Initial observation | Time-study the current changeover on video, break it down into elements | Baseline: 87 min on average |
| Phase 1 — Separate external and internal setup | Identify what can be done while the line is running (prepare tools, stars, starwheels, labeling heads) | Reduction to 48 min |
| Phase 2 — Convert internal into external | Move to pre-adjustment everything that can be pre-configured (offline labeler calibration, crown height check in the workshop) | Reduction to 31 min |
| Phase 3 — Streamline internal operations | Eliminate unnecessary adjustments, remove screws in favor of quick systems, replace clamps with bayonets | Reduction to 22 min |
4.3. Mapping of format changeover elements
A "standard" changeover from 33 cL returnable glass to 50 cL can has these elements, with typical observed times in European plants:
| Element | Average time (min) | Type | Optimization |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clear the line of the previous product (purge) | 4-7 | Internal | Reducible with a final CO₂ pig |
| Dismantling of washer stars | 6-9 | Internal | Convertible to external with pre-adjustment |
| Changing filler nozzles | 8-12 | Internal | Critical: use quick-change system |
| Labeler height adjustment | 5-8 | Internal | Convertible to external + digital preset |
| Changing crowner head (crown cap → screw cap) | 6-10 | Internal | Stock of pre-adjusted heads |
| Changing shrink film | 3-5 | Internal | Reducible with dual reel |
| Start-up and ramp-up to speed | 8-14 | Internal | Reducible with optimized CIP |
| Total without SMED | 40-65 min | ||
| Total after SMED | 15-25 min | Reduction on the order of 40-75 % |
4.4. The role of MTM in SMED
Where SMED really shines is in the rating of each element. Without MTM, times are argued "by eye" between production, maintenance and engineering. With MTM, each element is assigned a TMU that is contrasted with the timed value. This detects:
- Operations with slack (timed > 150 % of TMU): lack of standardized method, insufficient training.
- Operations with dead time (timed < 70 % of TMU): the operator is probably cutting corners or the method is not well designed.
- Operations with coherent values (timed = 90-110 % TMU): method well learned, basis for SMED.
Indicative industry example: the case published by iLEAN on industrial beer describes the validation of brand and format changeovers in packaging with machine vision; a reduction of format changeovers from 87 to 22 minutes, with OEE from 62 % to 74 % and about 14.000 additional cases/month, is an indicative example of the impact of a well-executed SMED project.
5. Simulated practical case: 360° audit in a multi-product plant
5.1. Audit context
A multi-product beverage plant in central Spain (simulated practical case, "Plant B") with two operating lines:
- Line A: non-returnable glass, 36.000 BPH, Krones isobaric filler.
- Line B: can + PET, 24.000 BPH, Sidel dual filler.
Estimated annual production: 1,8 million hectoliters/year (representing approximately 4,4 % of national beer production, estimated at 41,29 million hectoliters according to the Socioeconomic Report 2024 by Cerveceros de España). The audit team (3 methods engineers over 5 weeks) carried out MTM-1 time studies on both lines, micro-stop analysis with Work Sampling and SMED breakdown of the 6 most frequent format changeovers.
5.2. Time-study results
| Variable | Pre-audit | Post-audit | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|
| OEE Line A | 64 % | 75 % | +11 points |
| OEE Line B | 59 % | 68 % | +9 points |
| Availability | 87 % | 91 % | +4 points |
| Performance | 81 % | 88 % | +7 points |
| Quality | 91 % | 94 % | +3 points |
| Average format changeover time | 78 min | 26 min | -67 % |
| Micro-stops per shift (>30 s) | 14 | 5 | -64 % |
5.3. Five concrete actions identified
- Filler nozzle change with quick-change system: 12 min → 3 min. Investment: ~18.000 €.
- Dual reel for shrink film: eliminates film change time. Investment: ~6.000 €.
- Pre-adjustment trolleys for the labeler: converts 8 min of internal setup into external. Investment: ~4.500 €.
- SMED spreadsheet with reference videos: standardizes the method among the 6 changeover operators.
- Micro-stop analysis with Work Sampling: identifies 3 recurring patterns (jam in the depalletizer, level sensor failure, jam in the pasteurization tunnel) that explain 70 % of the micro-stops.
5.4. Payback calculation
The total cost of the improvement project was ~28.500 € (equipment + consulting). The 14.000 additional cases/month (at the internal transfer price between lines) are equivalent to about 84.000 €/month of additional revenue (14.000 × 6 €) and about 29.400 €/month of gross margin (35 % industrial margin). The project payback was about 29 days on the additional gross margin (28.500 € ÷ 29.400 €/month).
6. How to integrate time study into a digital BPH plant
6.1. Automatic capture with PLC and SCADA
A modern line has passage sensors at each station: when a bottle triggers the filler sensor, the PLC records the timestamp. With that information, a SCADA tool calculates in real time:
OEE tiempo real = A × P × Q
A = (tiempo_en_marcha) / (tiempo_planificado)
P = (BPH_reales) / (BPH_nominales)
Q = (unidades_conformes) / (unidades_totales)
The advantage of the PLC over the manual stopwatch is that it measures 100 % of the bottles (not a sample), and records micro-stops with millisecond precision. The disadvantage is that it only captures what the sensor sees, not what the operator does.
6.2. The MTM layer above the PLC
The PLC tells you what happens, not why it happens. For the "why" you need an upper layer based on MTM and Work Sampling:
- MTM, as the sector's predetermined method, is applied to manual operations (format changeovers, adjustments, CIP cleaning) when it is of interest to estimate without timing every micro-movement.
- Work Sampling is applied to support operations (pallet feeding, reject removal, visual inspections). It makes it possible to know what % of the time the operator spends on VA, NVA or IMP.
The PLC + MTM + Work Sampling combination is what distinguishes a serious time study from a "dashboard OEE analysis".
6.3. CronometrasApp as a field tool
CronometrasApp (developed by ProdCont for industrial time studies) is designed precisely for this scenario: time study with a digital stopwatch and synthetic performance rating on the scale in use (Bedaux 60-80 or centesimal 100-133), with configurable ILO and TAL allowances and export to PDF, Excel or JSON with the standard time calculation chain. It allows the methods engineer to spend more time observing and less time counting manually.
7. Typical risks of time study on BPH lines
| Risk | Cause | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|
| Undersizing allowances for wet environments | Forgetting the ILO +5/+10 % allowance | Apply the ILO allowance table by environmental condition and measure RH/T with a data logger |
| Confusing nominal BPH with real BPH | Using the inverse of the nameplate figure | Calculate OEE with PLC/SCADA data over 4-8 weeks |
| Timing the operator when the PLC already measures | Duplicating measurement, generating confusion | Use the stopwatch only for manual elements; the PLC for automatic ones |
| Ignoring the bottleneck in the bottle washer (returnable glass) | Assuming the filler is the bottleneck | Time-study each station separately, identify the one with the lowest rate |
| Over-rating the operator's pace | The operator works at a higher pace under observation (Hawthorne effect) | Blind sampling with video, remove the auditor's presence during sampling |
| Applying SMED without standardizing the prior method | The changeover is done "as always", differently each time | Make videos of changeovers before and after, train with the videos |
8. Conclusion and next steps
Time-studying a beer or soft drink bottling line is not timing bottles: it is breaking each station down into MTM elements, contrasting them with the PLC's nominal rate, identifying the real bottleneck (which is usually not the filler), applying the ILO allowances for damp and hot environments, and attacking format changeovers with SMED. In published industry cases, improvements on the order of +9-12 OEE points in 4-6 months are documented, with paybacks on the order of weeks (indicative figures).
To get started tomorrow in your plant:
- Collect 4 weeks of PLC data (real BPH, stoppages, rejects) and calculate the average OEE broken down into A × P × Q.
- Time-study with MTM-2 the 6 most frequent format changeovers (several measurements per element, according to the observed variability).
- Apply the ILO allowance table by environment (damp, hot, noisy).
- Run an SMED pilot on the most critical format changeover (the one with the highest frequency or longest time).
- Establish a 30-60-90 action plan with measurable OEE targets.
If you want to go deeper into how to apply this framework or need a case applied to your specific plant, at ProdCont we carry out 360° audits of beverage bottling lines with the framework described in this article.
References and sources
- Cerveceros de España — Socioeconomic Report on the Beer Sector in Spain 2024 — 41,29 million hectoliters produced in Spain in 2024.
- Sunswell — Beer bottling lines at 36.000 BPH — technical filling capacity in PET.
- Co.Mac — MASTER RS GLASS/PET up to 90.000 BPH — nominal speed of industrial beer fillers.
- Leybold — Beer bottle filling up to 80.000 BPH — typical isobaric filling range.
- SYMESTIC — OEE Benchmarks by Industry 2026 — average OEE values vs. world-class by sector.
- iFactory — OEE for FMCG Manufacturing (beverages) — FMCG/beverage operational metrics.
- iLEAN — Brand changeover in industrial beer validated with AI vision — brand changeover case with SMED + machine vision.
- Cronometras — SMED with MTM: Changeover time reduction — 4-phase technical SMED method with MTM.
- AETCM — Mahou, Damm, Heineken and Estrella Galicia account for 9 out of every 10 beers — concentration of the Spanish beer sector.
Simulated practical case. Example built for teaching purposes from plausible sector parameters. It does not correspond to a real Cronometras implementation nor to a specific client: the figures (Plant B, OEE from 64 % to 75 %, payback of about 29 days) are a composition of ranges published in open literature, not attributable to a specific plant. Any mention of sector companies (Mahou San Miguel, Damm, Hijos de Rivera, Heineken, Krones, Sidel, SÜKAT/Sunswell, Co.Mac., Leybold) refers to their public presence in the sector, not to a commercial relationship with ProdCont.
Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800
If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.