Multiple Man-Machine Chart

Multiple Man-Machine Chart

• Cronometras Team

How to calculate optimal machine coupling and industrial profitability with the multiple man-machine chart: key variables, cost analysis, ergonomics and methods engineering.

Beyond the Chart: The Group Process Chart as a Financial Instrument

In contemporary industrial engineering, viewing the Man-Machine Chart (M-M) merely as a graphical representation tool is a costly miscalculation. In the 2025 operating environment, where digitalization and Industry 4.0 demand millimeter precision, this tool evolves from being a time record into a mathematical profitability equation.

The real purpose of a group process chart is not only to visualize the simultaneity of tasks, but to solve the fundamental dilemma of technical productivity: the balancing act between Direct Labor (DL) saturation and asset availability (OEE). Whereas classical engineering sought to maximize operator occupancy, the modern view —based on Total Unit Cost— seeks the break-even point where the cost of machine idling does not exceed the payroll savings.

For plant engineering departments, the M-M chart is the bridge between shop-floor time study and the income statement.

Mathematical Foundations: Critical Variables in Asset Assignment

To carry out rigorous machine coupling, we must abandon empirical estimates and break down the production cycle into precise time vectors. The validity of the model depends on the accuracy of the following variables:

  1. TextT_{ext} (External/Service Work Time): Sum of the elements that the operator must necessarily perform while the machine is stopped (loading, unloading, setup).
  2. TintT_{int} (Internal Work Time): Elements performed by the operator while the machine is processing automatically (quality inspection, deburring, part filling).
  3. TmqT_{mq} (Automatic Running Time): Autonomous machine cycle time.
  4. twt_w (Travel Time): The critical variable in non-cellular layouts. It represents the transit between units.

Calculation of the theoretical number of machines ($N$)

According to ILO standards and traditional methods engineering, the theoretical number of machines that one operator can attend is defined as:

N=Text+TmqText+twN = \frac{T_{ext} + T_{mq}}{T_{ext} + t_{w}}

However, this formula assumes an ideal scenario with no variability. In practice, relying solely on this calculation can lead to invisible bottlenecks. To validate the real workload and detect hidden idle times before applying the formula, it is advisable to conduct a preliminary work sampling study. Tools such as WorkSamp make it possible to carry out Work Sampling studies with statistical rigor, identifying the actual proportion of twt_w and non-productive activities that the theoretical formula tends to underestimate.

Cost Analysis and the Phenomenon of Machine Interference

The senior engineer knows that the theoretical NN is not always the economic NN. When assigning multiple machines, we face the phenomenon of Machine Interference, where one or more units wait for attention while the operator tends to another.

Economic Assignment vs. Theoretical Assignment

The objective is to minimize Total Unit Cost ($C_u$), not necessarily to maximize gross output per operator.

Cu=Cop+N⋅CmqN⋅PrealC_u = \frac{C_{op} + N \cdot C_{mq}}{N \cdot P_{real}}

Where CopC_{op} is the operator hourly cost and CmqC_{mq} the machine hourly cost (including depreciation and energy). If the machine cost is high (e.g. 5-axis CNC machining centers), it is preferable to accept operator waiting times to guarantee an OEE close to 100%.

Static charts assume perfect cycles (Synchronous Interference). Reality is stochastic: machines experience minor stoppages, jams, or cycle variations. To model this correctly in environments with more than 4 machines, the use of Ashcroft Tables or discrete-event simulation is mandatory.

To feed these simulation models with reliable data, we cannot rely on spot time studies. A history of stoppages and actual cycle times is required. This is where solutions such as Induly are critical, since they make it possible to capture real OEE and technical downtime, providing the hard data needed to calculate stochastic interference accurately.

2025 Industrial Standards: Human Factors and Cognitive Ergonomics

Assigning multiple machines exponentially increases mental workload. In compliance with standard UNE-EN ISO 10075, workstation design must consider distributed vigilance as a fatigue factor.

  • Recalculation of Coefficients ($K_f$): Standard fatigue allowances (e.g. 4-5%) are insufficient in multiple M-M environments. The strain of maintaining synchronization requires adjusted coefficients to prevent performance degradation at the end of the shift.
  • Privacy and Data: Capturing machine states via SCADA to generate these charts must comply with the Digital Disconnection Law and privacy agreements. At Cronometras, we advocate measuring the process, not policing the individual.

Integration with Predetermined Time Systems (MTM and MOST)

The stopwatch is a validation tool, not a design tool. For high-level methods engineering, the cycle must be built before the physical plant exists.

  • Pre-implementation design: Using MOST (Maynard Operation Sequence Technique), we can simulate TextT_{ext} and validate whether a work cell will allow one operator to attend 3 machines before making the capital investment (CAPEX).
  • Objectivity: The use of MTM-2 standards eliminates the analyst's subjective "activity judgment", providing an indisputable normal time before works councils or audits.

Diagnosis and Technical Solutions for Plant Optimization

Based on our technical market research (Report 05-2025), we identify three common pathologies and their corrections:

Case A - Machine Idling (Low OEE)

  • Symptom: The operator is at 100% saturation, but the machines have excessive waiting times.
  • Technical Solution: Application of SMED to convert internal times ($T_{int}$) into external or automated ones. Reducing TextT_{ext} frees up operator capacity to meet machine demand.

Case B - Operator waiting time (Low saturation)

  • Symptom: Machines running, operator in passive waiting for >40% of the cycle.
  • Technical Solution: "Hidden Time Work" strategies. Introduce value-added tasks (dimensional quality control, manual deburring, palletizing) during TmqT_{mq}.

Case C - Layout Inefficiency

  • Symptom: The twt_w vector exceeds 15% of the total cycle time.
  • Technical Solution: Redesign of "U"-shaped cells to minimize the Euclidean distance between loading points. This reduces physical fatigue and increases the possible attendance frequency.

Conclusion: Return on Investment (ROI) through Methods Engineering

Optimization through the Multiple M-M Chart is not an aesthetic exercise; it is an efficiency audit. Production standards cannot be based on historical averages or intuition.

The final balance requires a triad: technical efficiency (calculated with precision), ergonomic feasibility (respecting human factors) and economic profitability (minimum unit cost). Only through scientific measurement and the use of advanced data management tools such as Induly for plant control and WorkSamp for methods diagnosis can a sustainable ROI be guaranteed in modern industry.


Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800

If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.

👉 Request the study from €800 · More about Cronometras

Did you find this useful?

Share this article with your professional network