Time Study in Warehouses and Picking

Time Study in Warehouses and Picking

• Cronometras Team

Why distribution centers must move from stopwatch-based estimates to MTM and MOST methods: work sampling, PTS systems, ergonomics compliance and LMS validation.

In the management of Distribution Centers (CeDi), intuition is an unacceptable financial risk. When the Picking and Order Preparation subsector statistically represents between 55% and 65% of total OPEX (Operational Expenditure), unmanaged variability translates directly into margin erosion.

However, the operational reality of the warehouse is defined by its "entropy": high variability in locations (XYZ coordinates), SKU geometry and demand fluctuation. In this scenario, historical estimates ("it has always taken this long") or simple arithmetic averages are technically and financially dangerous.

This technical article breaks down why it is imperative to migrate from subjective estimation to Methods Engineering (MTM/MOST) in order to secure productivity, validate LMS algorithms and ensure ergonomic regulatory compliance towards 2025.


The Fallacy of Direct Time Study in Logistics Environments

Classic industrial time study (standard BS 3138 or UNE 14002) is the gold standard in repetitive production lines. However, applying a "snapback" or "cumulative" time study in a warehouse without a prior statistical analysis is a methodological error.

The Coefficient of Variation (CV) as a Limiting Factor

From the standpoint of time engineering, any task whose Coefficient of Variation (CV) exceeds 20% invalidates direct time taking as the sole data source for establishing a reliable standard. In logistics, this CV skyrockets due to uncontrolled variables:

  1. Geographical Dispersion: The distance between slot A and B varies with every order.
  2. SKU Geometry: Performing a pick from a master case is not the same as from a loose unit (each).
  3. Stochastic Interferences: Forklift traffic, crossings with stacker cranes and aisle congestion.

The Need for Work Sampling

To neutralize this variance, and following the guidelines of the OIT (Introduction to Work Study), it is mandatory to carry out Work Sampling prior to setting the standard. This statistical procedure makes it possible to determine precisely the percentage of time devoted to contingencies and interruptions, ensuring that the allowances applied to Normal Time (TN) reflect operational reality rather than obsolete theoretical tables.


Technical Anatomy of the Picking Cycle (AS-IS Breakdown)

To optimize, we must first dissect the cycle through the lens of Lean Logistics. The aggregated data from our audits in the Iberian Peninsula reveal an alarming time distribution in unoptimized operations:

  • Travel (Travel Time - Muda): Accounts for 50-60% of the total cycle time. It is "non-vigorous time" and represents the greatest waste. Its reduction does not depend on the operator, but on Slotting engineering and Batch Picking algorithms.
  • Extraction (Value Added): Only 10-15% of the cycle adds real value (the physical moment of the pick).
  • Cognitive Inefficiency: Between 10-15% is lost in "Search and Location". This reveals failures in the warehouse's visual standardization and signage.

Predetermined Time Systems (PTS) in Logistics: MOST vs. MTM

Modern engineering demands eliminating the subjectivity inherent in the analyst's "pace appraisal" (Performance Rating - Bedaux/OIT Scale). The solution is the use of Predetermined Time Systems (PTS).

Why PTS Are Superior in Warehousing

PTS calculate time based on the method, not on observing the operator. This makes it possible to model process times that do not yet exist or to validate whether the times required by the WMS/SGA are realistic.

1. BasicMOST and MaxiMOST (Maynard Operation Sequence Technique)

For logistics, MTM-1 is usually excessively detailed and costly to maintain. MaxiMOST is the preferred standard for long and non-repetitive cycles. It focuses on the movement of objects:

MOST Technical Sequence Example: A10 B0 G1 A10 B0 P3 A0

Where:

  • A10: Considerable travel (Action Distance).
  • G1: Get a light box.
  • P3: Position (Put) with adjustment.
  • Accuracy: ±5% with a confidence level of 95%.

2. MTM-Logistics

When greater precision is required in movement ergonomics, we use MTM-Logistics. This system makes it possible to differentiate the Normal Time (TN) scientifically according to the height of the location:

  • The TN for a pick at Level 1 (floor) includes "Bend Down" and "Stand Up" movements (Body Motions).
  • The TN for a pick at Level 3 (mid-height) eliminates these macro-movements, reducing the cycle.

2025 Regulatory Framework: Ergonomics, Fatigue and Algorithms

Time engineering does not happen in a legal vacuum. The Labor Inspectorate and the Health and Safety Committees are increasing their scrutiny of imposed work rates (Art. 35 ET).

ISO 11228-1 Compliance and the NIOSH Equation

Manual lifting is critical. A standard time ($TE$) is calculated as: $$TE = TN \times (1 + Suplementos)$$

Towards 2025, the calculation of these Allowances (Rest Coefficients) can no longer be based on a "fixed 4%". A dynamic calculation is required that integrates:

  1. Energy Expenditure: Working metabolism (Kcal/min).
  2. NIOSH Equation: Time penalty based on the weight, frequency and vertical distance of the load.
  3. ISO 11228-1: Force and repetition limits.

Algorithm Audit (Rider Act / GDPR)

With the transposition of European directives on platform work and algorithmic management, companies must demonstrate the transparency of their times. If your Pick-to-Voice system dictates a target of 200 boxes/hour, CRONOMETRAS must validate that this target is achievable by a qualified operator at normal pace (100 OIT), protecting the company against claims for psychosocial risks or "techno-stress".


From Factory OEE to OLE (Overall Logistics Effectiveness)

To monitor the health of the process, we adapt industrial OEE to the logistics flow through OLE:

  1. Availability: Time lost due to system Downtime (WMS/SGA crashes, breakdowns in stacker cranes or lack of battery charge in PDAs).
  2. Performance: The ratio between Actual Pieces/Hour vs. the Technical Standard (calculated with MOST).
  3. Quality: The impact of picking errors (reverse logistics) and the time devoted to reconditioning, deducted from total productive time.

CRONOMETRAS Solution: LMS Audit and Validation

Many operations directors work with Labor Management Systems (LMS) — SAP EWM, Manhattan or JDA modules — that contain "Flat Times" poorly configured by default.

Our technical value proposition focuses on three pillars:

  1. Technical LMS Audit: We validate your current standard times using MaxiMOST to detect deviations between the algorithm and physical reality.
  2. Scientific Parameterization: We adjust your system's base times considering matrix variables: weight, volume, packaging type and anthropometry.
  3. Neutral Third Party: We act as an objective technical arbitrator between Management and the Works Council. We provide irrefutable data based on international standards to ensure "Industrial Peace" in collective agreement and productivity bonus negotiations.

Conclusion

Time engineering in the modern warehouse is not about "making people run faster". It is about predicting the real installed capacity, optimizing the flow through methods and protecting occupational health with scientific data.

Do not leave your OPEX in the hands of intuition.

Request a Picking Time Study Audit. Our engineers certified in MTM and MOST will validate your standards for an efficient and compliant 2025.

[Contact CRONOMETRAS Engineering]


Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800

If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.

👉 Request the study from €800 · More about Cronometras

Did you find this useful?

Share this article with your professional network