In an industrial ecosystem where machinery OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) has been optimized to near technical limits, residual variability and efficiency losses hide almost exclusively in the human factor.
For industrial engineers and plant managers in high-precision sectors—such as electronics, Tier-1 automotive, or medical devices—the 2025 challenge is clear: for very short cycles, global timing alone is not enough. When cycle time drops below 0.8 minutes, the "snapback" methodology is incapable of capturing process reality.
The only way to reduce cycle times without compromising quality or ergonomics is Forensic Method Engineering: the atomic decomposition of manual work into its 18 fundamental motions, known as Therbligs.
This article breaks down how to transform work measurement through micro-motion segregation, using therblig analysis and, where it fits the task, sector predetermined time systems such as MTM (Methods-Time Measurement).
The Collapse of Traditional Timing in Micro-mechanics
Attempting to optimize a fine assembly line with global timing alone —even with a stopwatch and synthetic pace rating (apreciación sintética del ritmo)— reaches its resolution limits in micro-second motions. Micro-motion analysis reveals what a global reading cannot see.
Analyst Physiological Limitations
The human eye has a critical perception latency. It is physically impossible for an analyst to consistently capture time intervals of less than 0.04 minutes (2.4 seconds). In fine assembly, where a "Grasp" motion can last milliseconds, conventional timing introduces an unacceptable statistical error.
Fine Assembly Technical Definition
To apply Technique #13, we define the work environment under the following critical conditions:
- High Repetitiveness: Short cycles (< 0.8 min).
- High Visual Load: Constant focus needed.
- Micro-mechanics: Handling components with dimensions < 10mm.
The Rating Question
Pace rating (apreciación sintética del ritmo) is an agile and simple system, although it requires trained analysts; sector predetermined time systems (PTS) like MTM-1 or MOST avoid rating altogether. In either case, an operator may appear fast by moving hands quickly but generating technical waste. Technique TE-13 eliminates this subjectivity: standard time is a function of the method, not apparent speed.
Anatomy of Technique #13: Efficient vs. Inefficient Therblig Segregation
Frank and Lillian Gilbreth's concept is not ancient history; it is the fundamental basis of Cobot programming and current MTM standards. The classic list comprises 18 therbligs, each with its standard code, habitually classified into two groups:
1. Effective Therbligs (they advance the operation)
They physically transform the product or advance the operation:
- Transport Empty (TE) (reach), Transport Loaded (TL) (move), Grasp (G), Release Load (RL), Preposition (PP), Assemble (A), Disassemble (DA) and Use (U).
2. Ineffective Therbligs (waste, to be reduced)
They add time and ergonomic load without advancing the operation:
- Search (Sh), Find (F), Select (St), Hold (H), Position (P), Inspect (I) (unless it is a defined critical quality operation), Plan (Pn), Unavoidable Delay (UD), Avoidable Delay (AD) and Rest (R).
Mathematical Objective: Maximize Effective Therblig density within total Cycle Time, driving Ineffective Therbligs to zero.
[Suggested Visual Element: Pie Chart comparing "Cycle Time Distribution: Value Added vs. Inefficient Therbligs (Before and After)"]
Simulated Practical Case: The 3 Cycle Time "Vampires" in Fine Assembly
This example was built for educational purposes and does not correspond to a real implementation of the product or to a specific client. In this illustrative example, around 40% of the time in non-optimized lines (illustrative example) is lost in three critical inefficiencies.
1. The Hidden Cost of Search (Sh) and Select (St)
- Root Cause: Chaotic arrangement of bulk materials and lack of gravity feeding.
- Cognitive Impact: These are "Mental Therbligs". They increase cognitive load and visual fatigue, penalized by OHS Law and new psychosocial risk regulations.
- Technical Solution: Apply the Fixed Location Principle. The part should never be "searched for"; it must appear at an exact point (vibratory or gravity feeders). If the eye has to travel to find the part, the method is incorrect.
2. Position (P) and Tolerance Penalty
In MTM systems, not all positionings are equal.
- MTM Data: There is a difference of up to 5.6 TMU (Time Measurement Units) between a Class 1 positioning (loose/no pressure) and a Class 3 (exact fit/pressure).
- Tooling Engineering: The methods engineer must collaborate with tooling design to implement conical guides and physical Poka-yokes. The goal is to reduce motion "Class", allowing fluid assembly without need for precise visual alignment.
3. Hold (H): Maximum Inefficiency
- Technical Verdict: "The human hand is a high-complexity assembly tool, not a bench vise".
- Correction: Any instance of Hold (left hand holding base part while right works) is a 50% inefficiency in limb usage. Implementing quick-action fixtures is mandatory to free both hands and allow a balanced Simo-Chart.
"Cronometras Std." Measurement Methodology (Step by Step)
To audit and correct these micro-motions, we don't use stopwatches, we use imaging technology.
- High Speed Capture: Video recording at minimum 60 fps to "freeze" micro-motion and analyze frame by frame.
- Simo-Chart (Simultaneous Motion Cycle Chart):
- Y-Axis: Time (expressed in TMU or ten-thousandths of an hour).
- X-Axis: Left Hand vs. Right Hand Activity.
- Imbalance Detection: Visual analysis allows identifying gaps.
- Technical Example: If RH performs Assemble (A) and LH is in Hold (H) or Unavoidable Delay (UD), we have a flagrant imbalance that must be corrected by redistributing workload or improving tooling.
[Suggested Visual Element: Simo-Chart fragment showing RH/LH imbalance and its correction via fixture]
Regulatory Framework and Ergonomics (Spain 2025)
Justifying standard times in 2025 requires solid regulatory backing, especially before works councils and safety audits.
- UNE-EN ISO 11228-3: This standard regulates handling of light loads at high frequency. Therblig analysis is documentary proof to validate that motion frequency is not injurious.
- Standard Justification: By basing standard time on MTM and Therbligs, discussion shifts from "operator speed" (subjective) to "work method" (objective).
- Allowances Reduction: By eliminating fatigue-inducing Therbligs (e.g. Hold (H) and Unavoidable Delay (UD)), rest coefficients (fatigue allowances) can representatively be adjusted downwards legitimately, resulting in a more competitive but less arduous standard for the worker.
Cronometras Technical Solution: Plant Implementation
For plants seeking to adopt Technique #13, we propose the following consultative workflow:
Step 1: Micro-motion Audit
Mapping potentially Type II (Delays) and III (Mental Elements) Therbligs via video analysis at bottleneck stations.
Step 2: Time Normalization
Normalizing times with a sector system like MTM-1, or by observing real work with synthetic pace rating (apreciación sintética del ritmo). Both reduce operator variability and establish a base time founded on human motion physics.
Step 3: Job Redesign (Micro Layout)
Moving Grasp (G) zones closer to the Normal Work Zone (35-40cm radius from elbow). The goal is minimizing long Transport Empty (TE) and Transport Loaded (TL) motions, which consume most time and generate most shoulder fatigue.
Expected ROI: Eliminating Search and Select alone can cut cycle time noticeably, without requiring massive automation investments.
Conclusion: Precision Methods Engineering
In the 2025 industrial scenario, we cannot afford to pay wages for motions that do not transform the product. Specialized Technique #13 is not just a measurement tool; it is an efficiency philosophy integrating technical productivity and occupational health.
Fine assembly requires precision, and precision requires data. Stop timing waste and start designing value.
[Suggested Visual Element: Infographic of 18 Therbligs with their standard symbols, categorized into Effective and Ineffective]
Is your plant losing efficiency in micro-motions invisible to the human eye? Request a time study with the Cronometras team today.
[>> Contact Methods Engineering]
If you want to identify and eliminate these unproductive motions in your assembly lines, ProdCont can help you measure and correct them.
This article is also available in Spanish: Técnica Especializada #13: Análisis de Therbligs en montaje fino.
Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800
If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.